Home > Selling at Auction > Why Sell at Auction Instead of a Shop?

Why Sell at Auction Instead of a Shop?

By: Chris Nickson - Updated: 27 Jan 2018 | comments*Discuss
Auctions Online Auction In-person

Selling items at auction is a gamble. The price could go through the roof – in which case you’re in the money – or it could remain close to the floor in which case you lose out. Of course, you can protect yourself by using a reserve price (which means the bidding has to go over the price in order for the item to be sold), but that costs you money as you have to pay the auction company.

So when should you sell at auction and when should you simply put an ad in the paper and sell for a fixed price?

Selling at a Fixed Price

To be honest, most common goods are best sold at a fixed price. There needs to be some value, be it age or rarity, to warrant selling an item at auction and hope to make a good return from it.

That applies also to books or old LPs or CDs. There might well be millions of copies out there – who would bid any big money on, say, The Eagles Greatest Hits? – so you’re better off selling it. (if you’re feeling generous, try Freecycle instead).

So first you need to take a look at what you’re selling. If, say, you’ve taken out an old fireplace surround from your house and it’s in good condition, are you better off selling for a fixed price through an ad (or even to a salvage furniture dealer) or by auction? Do your research. Find out a little about the style of the piece and its age. When you know more, you can make an informed decision – and also write a better description.

Selling at Auction

If you have an item with some rarity – a limited edition of a CD or toy, for instance – it might well be worth selling it at auction. Whether you sell at an online auction or an in-person auction can depend on several factors. Online is easiest, taking the least effort on your part, but might not bring you the highest price if the item is specialised or very rare.

If it’s valuable and has to do with music or movie memorabilia, as an example, you might want to enter it into a specialised auction, carried out by several auction houses regularly. Much the same criteria apply to vintage cars.

Setting the Price

If you choose to sell without a reserve price, then you need to establish a starting price for bids. If you’re reasonably confident people will bid well on the item, you can afford to start with a low opening price. If you’re more cautious, keep the opening price relatively high – but not so high as to put people off bidding; it’s a fine line.

Again, it pays to do your research and discover the selling price of similar items. The more knowledge you have, the more you might end up receiving for your item. But always remember that there’s no guarantee your item will fetch a similar price.

In the right instance, selling at auction can pay off handsomely. Antiques are a booming market and if you pick the right auction, you can come out well ahead by putting your item in front of people who are interested in that particular thing. Note, though, that in most cases the big auction houses will only deal with high ticket items. Unless there’s something very rare about it, Sotheby’s won’t be handling your great-great Aunt Vi’s 19th century silver photo frame.

Use your common sense. Look around first. Research doesn’t need to take long. But it will pay off in the long run.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Not Happy. The three antique ivory okimonos I bought over 30 years that I no longer wished to keep, So I phoned a weekly auction house inLotts road,the director said to bring them in. Thinking they would make at least £400 close to what I paid for them, I drove to Chelsea The owner/ director said. they could go in the next auction with a reserve of £80 on two & 50 on the other. Knowing they were worth a lot more I asked fora £100 reserve each on the 20cm pair & £50 on the smaller one, too which he agreed. Never asked about a commission, assuming it would be usual 15%. Phone a few days later & was tould two pieces had sold but, one piece never made the reserve. Rather than spend another £30 on fuel to go & pick it up, I asked for it to put in the next auction with a just a £70 reserve: was sold. After phoning 3 times over the next 4 weeks I finally received a check for £97.70 from the £225 hammer sale. Details available includes £20 in 'commission' for the unsold item in the first auction & three £20 commissions for a £90,£55 & £80
GEOFFSE3 - 27-Jan-18 @ 10:08 PM
@emo31 - Ive included a link from the Property Ombudsman; Valuers & Auctioneers General Obligations which gives code of practice guildelines and advises how to complain. link here.
ExploreAuctions - 20-Nov-14 @ 2:58 PM
Is there a regulatory body , say ombudsman , that oversees the activities of auctioneers and auction houses.If so I would be grateful if you would give me their details. Thanks
emo31 - 20-Nov-14 @ 2:24 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Njahan
    Re: Consumer Law and Auction Goods
    I bought goods from a well-known auctioneers and due to lockdown they've been posting things out. I recently bought cosmetics of…
    15 February 2021
  • Paddy 12
    Re: Beware of the Invisible Bidder
    Hello . I recently won two items on a second hand tool auction,all though the auction was online ,the oppurnity was given to…
    26 November 2020
  • Dutchy
    Re: Consumer Law and Auction Goods
    I bought some new garden furniture at auction in May on the basis it was due 13/6. The furniture didn’t arrive but date kept…
    24 October 2020
  • dave
    Re: Buying Collectibles and Memorabilia at Auction
    bought a car at local auction and 6 months later it had been a category n insurance write off, can i take…
    12 September 2020
  • Pat
    Re: Auction House Commissions
    I'm putting a coin in auction and they have offerd me 0% comition to sell the item how do thay make money and is ther hidden charges…
    19 August 2020
  • Robbie
    Re: Selling Collectibles
    I have whole collection of “Gone With The Wind” items ie: books, plates, figurines, porcelain card with wooden display case, watch, small…
    18 February 2020
  • Tina
    Re: Selling Collectibles
    I have a unopened bottle of beer from The Brexit Beverages company article 50, one of the first batch made.. I wanted to know if it's worth…
    31 January 2020
  • None
    Re: Choosing Which Type of Auction to Sell At
    I have a portrait presented to me by the late Deputy First Minister for Northern Ireland, Mr Martin McGuinness.…
    26 January 2020
  • Mick
    Re: Consumer Law and Auction Goods
    I purchased an Edwardian bedroom suite from a reputable Auction house late september, I have just noticed holes (woodworm) in…
    16 December 2019
  • Mick
    Re: Consumer Law and Auction Goods
    I purchased a Edwardian bedroom suit from Auction house in late September have just noticed a number of holes (woodworm) on one…
    16 December 2019